University Web Developers

University Web Developers

One of the concerns I hear about social media seems to confuse social media with what I call asocial media; soapbox monologues on unmoderated blogs by anonymous posters with no interest in dialogue. In other words, what's social about one (or many) people posting flames without caring about the response?

In the perceived debate between controlled and uncontrolled messaging -- as false a dichotomy as "you're either with us or agin' us" -- is anyone managing in the nuanced area between, where editorial moderation and civilized discussion is valued? To what degree is the strategy of crowdsourcing ideas and selecting only some for action (as at change.gov and whitehouse.gov) instructive?

Are you involved in managing social media in the area between being-open-to-all-perspectives and being willing-to-moderate-which-will-be-heard? (Does it have to be all or nothing?) If so, how do you do it? ;)

Share

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I share this concern as well. I never want to censor content, but sometimes for the good of the community it needs to be done. In Seth Godin's book "Small is the New Big", in the topic of "Accountability", he talks about all the problems on the Web due to anonymity. He compares it to a workplace where all the employees come to work wearing a mask. They can say and do anything and there are no repercussions. In his words - "Anonymity is the enemy of civility".

I personally would like to make it a requirement that to participate on this site you have to be a real person, using your real name. Virtually all of the content I've had to ban has come from people who are anonymous and are posting content for their own gain rather than for the community. I hope we get a variety of opinions on this site because that is a tenet of good conversation. I just prefer to know who I'm talking to. In addition, I prefer to see members who use a picture of themselves as their avatar. For me, when I can put a name with a face it makes the conversation more human.

Reply to This

Right on.

Reply to This

Excellent points, Mark. This is the only "social" site where my avatar is an actual pic of me largely because of the reasons you point out.

The only place this would apply to my institution is our blog (hosted on blogger). We moderate the comments we get there, but if memory serves we only rejected a single comment and it was obvious spam, a problem that blogger seems to have addressed since then. The only entry we've had that generated any real debate was a discussion on the president's desire to make us a smoke free campus. We were pleasantly surprised when it didn't quickly turn into a flame war.

Other than that, in all honesty, we're still working on trying to get the sort of sticky content that generates enough discussion for us to even really worry about civility/censorship issues. :)

Reply to This

Our CMS (Ekklesia360 from Monk Development) requires that someone log in to the site in order to post a comment to a blog or a thread (or response to a thread) on our message boards. We still moderate the comments, as there has been at least one instance of SPAM in our online community, but I have yet to reject an actual comment, because that extra step of logging in helps ensure that someone is an actual person.

We really want to be intentional about encouraging open discussion and dialog, so I am not likely to reject a comment, unless it is obviously a flame or SPAM. We have had a couple of spirited conversations on a couple of our blog posts, but like Derek, most of our content (so far) hasn't been sticky enough to cause any real problems.

Reply to This

Speaking as a representative of the avatar-represented crowd - and a real person - let me say that the online world gives you a chance to play with your image or dispense with it entirely. Using an avatar - or a nickname - doesn't make you any less "human."

Reply to This

RSS

Elsewhere

Latest Activity

Employment Opportunities is one of the 12 main navigation links in the header of our Web site template. Therefore, it appears not only on the home page, but on almost every page of our site.
13 hours ago
Erik Espana, Rick Gould, Gloria Edwards and 3 more joined University Web Developers
14 hours ago
I just opened my account jfduguid (at) googlewave
14 hours ago
Off topic, but the hide/show social media icon bar on your site is very well done.
15 hours ago
Global footer that says "We're Hiring". It is one of our top visited pages.
16 hours ago
Thanks for the feedback - the backstory here is that our HR office has requested to be on the homepage, but the college's Web Advisory committee has been refusing the request. I thought a link in the global footer would be a nice solution, so I'm ...
16 hours ago
"Employment at SJC" is a link in our footer that is on every page, including the homepage. We also have a prominent link in the navigation one level down under our "About Us" section. It's one of our top hits also.
16 hours ago
Share your experiences using OmniUpdate CMS
16 hours ago
We have an Employment link in the footer of every page, including our home page.
16 hours ago
OmniUpdate’s CMS business is booming and we are looking for several Web Services Technicians. Help us grow our team.
18 hours ago
Yes, we list it on the homepage. Our HR person requested this as part of our redesign about a year ago and I thought it made sense.
18 hours ago
We have a "Jobs" link in our global footer.
18 hours ago
We do have a link at the bottom of the home page in the footer. We have gone one step further however, because the footer is a common include used across everyone of our pages that is in our new template. We have about 75% of our pages using it. I...
18 hours ago
shannon johnson added a discussion
hello uwebd! we're hiring a developer here @ Rensselaer's Experimental Media & Performing Arts Center in Troy, NY. www.empac.rpi.edu. We started this search last year but then went into a hiring freeze, and now have a window where we're quickly tr...
18 hours ago
I can tell you how we do it- I work in marketing on the web team. We control the front page. I'm the content person, so I make a lot of those judgment calls. For our specific design (www.oc.edu), there are a few guiding principles. For the top ...
18 hours ago
joleflow @ googlewave.com
19 hours ago
Georgiana Cohen added a discussion
What is the editorial process for your university homepage? Specifically, I'm curious about: - what type of content gets featured (news, events, blogs, social media, contests, etc.) - number of people making decisions about what content gets feat...
20 hours ago
It is a link on our homepage and is one of our top hits as well.
20 hours ago
We don't, but it is one of the first menu items from the top drop down menu. I would say it is worth it, especially if you are a large school. We're a small school (for example at this time we have 5 only openings on campus), but that page is one ...
20 hours ago
20 hours ago

An adjunct to UWEBD. UWEBD has been in existence for more than 10 years and is the very best email discussion list on the Internet, in any industry, on any topic.

About

© 2009   Created by Mark Greenfield

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy  |  Terms of Service

Sign in to chat!