University Web Developers

University Web Developers

This week A List Apart published a thought-provoking article called "Elevate Web Design at the University Level". The following quote hit the nail on the head for me: "I've yet to see anyone come out of a university program knowing what they need to know in order for us to hire them".

I've been thinking about this issue for over a decade. I've hired numerous people over the years and not one gained the skills they need from formal education. I've watched members of my staff get graduate degrees and listened to them express their complete frustration over how inadequate and inappropriate the curriculum was. I've taught graduate level classes and as an instructor, found the experience to be very frustrating.

As higher education web professionals, we are in a position to understand the issue and work with our institutions to improve it. So how do we move forward?

Tags: education, highered

Views: 20

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

More on the topic from the Chronicle:

Colleges Get Poor Grades on Teaching Web Fundamentals
Wow. Thanks Mark.

Some of the general trends from the discussions on other forums show up at the Chronicle. I see other people talking about the catch 22 of "you must have a Masters to teach, but how do you get a Masters when there aren't even that many decent Bachelors programs in the field?". And I see some people bringing in the accreditation requirement angle that's been missing from discussions at places like ALA. But given that their target audience is academic first and foremost and likely not at all web savvy, I'm saddened but not surprised to see stuff like "This article is very stupid." (and we're supposed to take anything else you have to say seriously after an opening like that?) and "You don’t even need to know how to code anymore to create decent web pages because of good programs such as MS Publisher or Dreamweaver."

Argh! Publisher isn't even a web authoring tool!

The uphill battle continues.
Yeah I read that comment too and all credibility that comment had went out the window when I read the bit about Publisher and Dreamweaver. OTOH, it really made it glaringly obvious how out of touch academia is with the field.
Sadly, the bit about the need for critical thinking and what not I would be inclined to agree with, had the first paragraph not made such a terrible first impression with me. :(
This is a lot like the model I experienced at Tennessee Technological University. The "lab" you speak of was unofficially affiliated. It was the Technology Institute. We handled faculty training and support; special projects related to grants; and even occasionally took on contract work from outside the campus like a real design firm. Most of the people who worked there were web design students. This was made easier because the director of the Institute was also the guy who taught all the WEBD courses.

The program was "multi-disciplinary". So we took a mix of mass communication, business, and computer science courses. The curriculum was set up so that most semesters you also had a WEBD course that helped tie all the concepts from these classes more directly to the web. I think that approach was both our greatest strength and our greatest weakness. It helped us produce very well rounded graduates who understood how to grow their skill set with just enough real world experience to have a leg up in the market vs. recent graduates with no work experience or portfolio to speak of.

But I think it also ended up being our downfall. As a multi-disciplinary program, we technically had no faculty. Bob was an English professor who just happened to teach all the WEBD courses (and no English courses). Technically, the faculty of the entire College of Arts and Sciences were available to assist us. But when Bob left, that didn't open up a spot for a web design instructor. That opened up a spot for a new English instructor. For the program to continue to work the way it did while I was there, they can't rely on any single instructor to fill that role. I'd love to see the WEBD courses be taught by a multi-disciplinary team or maybe have a moderator who facilitates discussion based on lectures given by a rotating roster of academics and working professionals. As it stands, I think they've become by-the-book courses taught by comp sci graduate students. The worst part is the books on the syllabi were never used in class. Those were resources we were expected to make use of outside of class. What's the value added to the student if the course is just a guided path through the exercises in a text they could buy and work through on their own?
Yes, this model is pretty close to what we have at Las Positas College. It's called the Design Shop, and it's a functioning business out of the Visual Communications program. It's mostly graphic and web design, and would benefit from some cross-discipline coursework in Computer Science.
There's an elephant lurking behind all this: You can't be a great web designer/developer/architect/reporter until and unless you understand how and why people live online.

It helps enormously to be one of those people who are online far too much. I suppose you could succeed also if you happen to be an incredible anthropologist of the online world, but I personally can't imagine why someone would know so much about a world and not be of it.

Which is a nice way of saying you can't teach it if you don't understand it.

In the previous segment of my career, running a major-metro online news operation as part of a newspaper company, I was amazed at how J-school grads were coming out indoctrinated in a print-only mentality as recently as just a few years ago. Their professors weren't evil monsters intentionally teaching them faulty information for kicks. They simply taught what they knew, and what they knew was newspapers.

Likewise, if you don't spend 3-4 hours a day steeping in the world of social media, shared video, mobile devices and database-driven, user-customizable experiences, you're going to be a professor that teaches the static web, circa 2004.

Solutions? How about an open-sourced curriculum, built by web professionals, that lays out a credible course of study? What about teaching media-literacy to kids in middle and high school? Hard to accomplish - of course - but would they be worth the effort?
I totally agree with the vast majority of what's being said here- I would love to see more interdisciplinary programs that combine writing, design, and computer science into a web developer curriculum.

Just a philosophical aside:
Believe it or not, I'm not sure that it's solely higher ed's responsibility to churn out designers who are "ready to go to work." That's called vocational training. I don't think it's a good idea for higher ed's to spoon feed students a specific vocation.

I feel that higher ed's job is to teach people how to think- to give them the mental tools to continue learning in their field. I was in class with many who expressed a similar frustration that "They're not teaching us what we need to know to work!"; yet I knew what I needed to know because I was working while I was in college.

I didn't wait for a faculty member (who were all really great teachers) to show me how to create a mask in Photoshop or write a div tag. I went out and just did it, using my design education to inform me on what communicated the idea most effectively.

It's called "initiative."
This is off topic, sort of. Has anyone noticed a trend where colleges are outsourcing their websites and dismissing their web staff?

Back on topic.
To be successful, know css, know photoshop, know a couple server side languages, have a handle on javascript, have a grip on a cms or two, Have the ability to Google out anything you don't know, have a good work ethic and you should be fine...until you get outsourced of course. I have yet to see someone that comes out of a degree program that is ready to hit the ground running. I have however seen web developers and designers that are self taught and have a passion for what they do that are.
What IS working is inviting industry professionals (regardless of their education) to come to teach the latest tools and trends. These are the people who are in touch and on top of what is happening.

Substitute real-world experience for their degree status and allow them to push the students beyond what they're getting currently. We've just unveiled our version of a mixed media major (web/video/audio/mash-up/interactive) and former students are very interested in coming back to teach.
I certainly agree there is a gap when it comes to web _____________ (fill in the blank). I think, without a doubt, web building requires multidisciplinary knowledge and collaborative/team-building skills. I've often referred to it
as the ultimate team sport of knowledge workers.

And the road to better instruction, or better educated professionals, it seems to me, is to ensure that any curriculum/degree/certificate in web _____________ touches on, not only the requisite software and design skills, but also includes IA, IT, writing, editing, and interpersonal/emotional skills, among others; and to echo my own background a bit -- courses in the history of science and technology and technical communication.

RSS

Elsewhere

Latest Activity

Daniel Bashaw replied to Kimbel Jeffers's discussion Office Reservation software
"Hi Kimbel -- Does you manual process include a checklist and workflow documentation? If not, it sounds to me like checklists and schedulers are your best next steps. You can structure and document what you do now, and then look at it to see if there…"
yesterday
Kimbel Jeffers replied to Kimbel Jeffers's discussion Office Reservation software
"The problem is we use a manual process right now and things keep falling through the cracks."
Thursday
Annette Spearman replied to Derek Tonn's discussion Freelance web design recommendations (small projects)
"Hi Derek, We can help you! I'll in box you all my info so we can connect and set up some time to talk. Annette "
Thursday
Mark Rothbaum posted a discussion

5-Minute Survey on Use of Facebook in Admissions

We're conducting our annual survey on Facebook and Admissions. Please take a few minutes to complete the survey at:http://www.varsityoutreach.com/FacebookSurvey/Our GoalOur goal is to explore trends related to how schools are using Facebook to reach out to prospective and admitted students.How Is the Data Used?All data will be shown in the aggregate. Answers from individual schools will not be released and will remain…See More
Thursday
Profile IconSang Yoon and Brittany Smith joined University Web Developers
Wednesday
Colleen Brennan-Barry posted a discussion

HighEdWeb Welcomes Steve Wozniak & Scott Stratten

HighEdWeb is very pleased to announce HighEdWeb 2013 Annual Conference opening keynote speaker Steve Wozniak and closing keynote speaker…See More
Wednesday
faris ahmed commented on social networking web design's blog post Megastar Media Webby Award Honorees
"wow thats amazing article .  your stuff never fails to amaze me honestly . great work as always :D  something i would like to add in is that  the entries each year are rapidly increasing .  but i think thats cause they take the…"
Wednesday
Lynn Zawie posted a discussion

Freelance Web Developer Needed

Stony Brook University web team is looking for some help coding a new design.  HTML5, CSS3, JQuery, Responsive Design expertise needed.  If you are interested in bidding on this project, I am happy to share more details.  Work would need to begin early summer.  ..LynnSee More
Tuesday
Sara Michel commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Great blog post by Higher Education Marketing on leveraging Google pay-per-click ad extensions for higher ed."
Tuesday
Sara Michel commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Check out Naropa University's new online magazine. Looks awesome! Great job team."
Monday
Norma J Dowell replied to Derek Tonn's discussion Freelance web design recommendations (small projects)
"Hi Derek! First of all, apologies for taking so long to respond! Secondly, I am not your web developer for such an issue, but if you can find someone to pick their brain and use as a sounding board, it may be all you need.  In the past, when I…"
Monday
Daniel Bashaw replied to Kimbel Jeffers's discussion Office Reservation software
"Hi Kimbel. I know you've been tasked with finding a software solution, though I'm wondering if you may need an interim step first: Does your institution have checklists covering all of the steps needed in on-boarding, relocating, and…"
Monday
Kimbel Jeffers posted a discussion

Office Reservation software

I've been tasked with finding a software tool that helps manage the onboarding and exit process of new and departing faculty. Ultimately i would like this software to management faculty office interms of when resources can be removed from a particular office and when a new faculty member can be moved in with the necessary resources. This tool should have notifications and alerts so there are no conflicts with someone being removed from a office and someone being placed in a office. Does anyone…See More
May 11
Sara Michel commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Congrats to Harper College on going live with their new online course catalog! Looks great!"
May 10
Helen Mosher joined Aaron Rester's group
May 9
Helen Mosher joined Mark Greenfield's group
May 9
Helen Mosher posted a status
"After 8 years being away from higher-ed communications work, I'm very interested in returning."
May 9
Will Martin is now a member of University Web Developers
May 6
Sarah McMaster replied to Katra Farah's discussion Online chat interfaces
"Thanks, Daniel. We don't currently have any livechat solution so this is new fact-finding territory for us! I will keep the forum posted as/if we are able to move forward."
May 3
Daniel Bashaw replied to Katra Farah's discussion Online chat interfaces
"In our case the impact of our current proprietary chat tool seems to be minimal, as it is little-used. It requires log-in with contact details and is slow to load. I don't have any metrics on its impact to back up my perception though. I expect…"
May 3

UWEBD has been in existence for more than 10 years and is the very best email discussion list on the Internet, in any industry, on any topic

About

© 2013   Created by Mark Greenfield.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service