University Web Developers

University Web Developers

Our Facebook is managed by a work study in the web department. We want the postings to be fresh and honest from a student perspective. One of our alumni was concerned about what he considers to be a personal posting other than stating simple facts by our monerator. He dosen't believe personal statements are beneficial. You/we can't control what people say on social networks. Doesn't that defeat the purpose? Once we start trying to censor it will open the flood gates to even more negative postings. If any of you have information to the contrary I would like to hear it. I'm open to hearing other perspectives on my understanding of Facebook and other social media.

Views: 8

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I went to look at your university's page and I wonder if you were referencing the world series comment. My personal opinion is that when you post as the university, you have should be EXTREMELY cautious in making polarizing statements. You can't always avoid offending people, but in that case your student worker was looking to ruffle feathers. Reasonable/rational or not, going after a sports team that has no association with your school probably isn't wise- as you can see from the backlash in the comments.

My opinion that I operate our social media out of is that some places are expected places to air personal opinions- like blogs- but when you speak on behalf of the university (as FB administrators do by default), then it's wise to avoid unnecessary polarizing topics.
Yes, I am referring to the World Series comments. How tight should we be pulling the reigns in? How do you balance freedom of speech while still allowing for that fresh student perspective?
Ann's got it.

I might add that freedom of speech doesn't enter into it. That's a constitutional freedom unrelated to this question.

What you're dealing with here is context of speech.

The EDU facebook page has a context. That context is that of a neutral institution that's using facebook expressing some genuine personality and facilitating a community.

The reason why the baseball comment stands out is that it's a personal statement of opinion regarding something that someone out there could take seriously.

The institution wouldn't say the same thing about your own sports team, why say it about someone else's.
I agree, this isn't about free speech as much as it is about the university appearing to take a position on an issue. Comments like that should be posted on students' personal accounts. Actually, I don't think students should even be managing the official University account - that's very risky. Universities have huge audiences all over the spectrum, and any official communication (which these kinds of account fall under) should always try to encourage pride and a positive image.

There's definitely a place for authentic student perspectives, but it should be very clear when something is written by a student, alum, or anyone other than an employee that can officially speak for the institution. Social media accounts make it very hard to be clear who is doing the talking behind a logo and the name of the university.

On my school's official FB account, even though we don't really have a plan on how to use it yet, I try very hard to post messages that the majority of our followers would enjoy and find value in so that they won't consider it spam and hide future updates on their news feed. It's definitely a challenge.
I agree with Ann and Charlie. Context here is key. And I do think that under the correct supervision, student workers or student ambassadors can effectively admin social media pages.
I read through the thread and there were two responses that I believe show that the post should not have been posted. "A Pennsylvania school should really be cheering for the Philadelphia team." and "So what happened to the Pennsylvania pride from a Pennsylvania school, who ever put the post up should realize that we root for the Phils, Flyers, Eagles , 76rs, Penguins, Pirates, and Steelers."

If your school is known for a large amount of Yankees fans in attendance, then there is some ok in the post.

Also, I'm interested in knowing if it is known to the Fans on your page that it is run by a student? If that is widely known the community might have reacted differently. But it looks like the community all believed it was a view point of the university. The poster went further to give a email to be contacted at that reflects upon the university. I did like the apology, but I was turned off when I saw they did not post an email where they could get a person with a name instead of "socialmedia"

The Fan page is an extension of the university's brand. It must represent the views of the university.
I want to thank everyone for their input. We had a meeting this morning about this an we agree with your views. The student realized his mistake, which is why he apologized. He has been spoken to and now understands who he represents and it won't happen again.

RSS

Elsewhere

Latest Activity

Daniel Bashaw replied to Kimbel Jeffers's discussion Office Reservation software
"Hi Kimbel -- Does you manual process include a checklist and workflow documentation? If not, it sounds to me like checklists and schedulers are your best next steps. You can structure and document what you do now, and then look at it to see if there…"
Friday
Kimbel Jeffers replied to Kimbel Jeffers's discussion Office Reservation software
"The problem is we use a manual process right now and things keep falling through the cracks."
Thursday
Annette Spearman replied to Derek Tonn's discussion Freelance web design recommendations (small projects)
"Hi Derek, We can help you! I'll in box you all my info so we can connect and set up some time to talk. Annette "
Thursday
Mark Rothbaum posted a discussion

5-Minute Survey on Use of Facebook in Admissions

We're conducting our annual survey on Facebook and Admissions. Please take a few minutes to complete the survey at:http://www.varsityoutreach.com/FacebookSurvey/Our GoalOur goal is to explore trends related to how schools are using Facebook to reach out to prospective and admitted students.How Is the Data Used?All data will be shown in the aggregate. Answers from individual schools will not be released and will remain…See More
Thursday
Profile IconSang Yoon and Brittany Smith joined University Web Developers
Wednesday
Colleen Brennan-Barry posted a discussion

HighEdWeb Welcomes Steve Wozniak & Scott Stratten

HighEdWeb is very pleased to announce HighEdWeb 2013 Annual Conference opening keynote speaker Steve Wozniak and closing keynote speaker…See More
Wednesday
faris ahmed commented on social networking web design's blog post Megastar Media Webby Award Honorees
"wow thats amazing article .  your stuff never fails to amaze me honestly . great work as always :D  something i would like to add in is that  the entries each year are rapidly increasing .  but i think thats cause they take the…"
Wednesday
Lynn Zawie posted a discussion

Freelance Web Developer Needed

Stony Brook University web team is looking for some help coding a new design.  HTML5, CSS3, JQuery, Responsive Design expertise needed.  If you are interested in bidding on this project, I am happy to share more details.  Work would need to begin early summer.  ..LynnSee More
Tuesday
Sara Michel commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Great blog post by Higher Education Marketing on leveraging Google pay-per-click ad extensions for higher ed."
Tuesday
Sara Michel commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Check out Naropa University's new online magazine. Looks awesome! Great job team."
May 13
Norma J Dowell replied to Derek Tonn's discussion Freelance web design recommendations (small projects)
"Hi Derek! First of all, apologies for taking so long to respond! Secondly, I am not your web developer for such an issue, but if you can find someone to pick their brain and use as a sounding board, it may be all you need.  In the past, when I…"
May 13
Daniel Bashaw replied to Kimbel Jeffers's discussion Office Reservation software
"Hi Kimbel. I know you've been tasked with finding a software solution, though I'm wondering if you may need an interim step first: Does your institution have checklists covering all of the steps needed in on-boarding, relocating, and…"
May 13
Kimbel Jeffers posted a discussion

Office Reservation software

I've been tasked with finding a software tool that helps manage the onboarding and exit process of new and departing faculty. Ultimately i would like this software to management faculty office interms of when resources can be removed from a particular office and when a new faculty member can be moved in with the necessary resources. This tool should have notifications and alerts so there are no conflicts with someone being removed from a office and someone being placed in a office. Does anyone…See More
May 11
Sara Michel commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Congrats to Harper College on going live with their new online course catalog! Looks great!"
May 10
Helen Mosher joined Aaron Rester's group
May 9
Helen Mosher joined Mark Greenfield's group
May 9
Helen Mosher posted a status
"After 8 years being away from higher-ed communications work, I'm very interested in returning."
May 9
Will Martin is now a member of University Web Developers
May 6
Sarah McMaster replied to Katra Farah's discussion Online chat interfaces
"Thanks, Daniel. We don't currently have any livechat solution so this is new fact-finding territory for us! I will keep the forum posted as/if we are able to move forward."
May 3
Daniel Bashaw replied to Katra Farah's discussion Online chat interfaces
"In our case the impact of our current proprietary chat tool seems to be minimal, as it is little-used. It requires log-in with contact details and is slow to load. I don't have any metrics on its impact to back up my perception though. I expect…"
May 3

UWEBD has been in existence for more than 10 years and is the very best email discussion list on the Internet, in any industry, on any topic

About

© 2013   Created by Mark Greenfield.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service