University Web Developers

University Web Developers

Hi all,

I need feedback on your institution's experience with the following CMS vendors:

* Day
* Ektron
* Sitecore
* Hannon Hill
* Fatwire

And/or your experience with these open source CMS products:

* Drupal
* TYPO3

Also do you have any experience with a support contract for Drupal or TYPO3, such
as from Acquia.com or Acqal.com?

And last:

Do you have any general tips on particularly outstanding or awful enterprise-level content management products?

Thank you for your time!

Rebecca

Tags: CMS, Content, Management, Systems

Views: 117

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

We built a CMS and have been supporting it since 2002. I constantly weight the pros/cons of starting fresh with a new CMS or building off the current one. Interesting to see what comes up in this conversation!
Hey Rebecca! Curious why you're not evaluating OmniUpdate? We've been a client for 4+ years here at SUNY New Paltz, and they have a killer New York State contract that saved us oodles of money.
Hey Rachel!

I would have loved to evaluate it, however they did not respond to our bid. I had no idea they had a NYS contract and will pass that along to our CMS team. Thank you so much for the info!

So are you happy with them?

Rebecca
I've been incredibly happy with them -- but more importantly, my end users love the product. I'd be happy to put you in touch with Michael Monina, their VP of Sales & our SUNY/NY rep.
That would be great Rachel!

And if any of you have comments on any of the other vendors I mentioned, I would appreciate the feedback on those as well.

Rebecca
Rebecca,

I took a quick look at the contract (on the ITEC site) and it appears to be a hosted version. Don't know if that's a factor.
I won't use any specific names of companies or vendors, but I will share some of our experiences in searching for a CMS. In the end, we ended up developing our own CMS because it was so difficult to get exactly what we wanted.

We issued an RFP a total of three times. The first RFP we issued, I believe we got 0 responses (that was before I was hired). The second RFP we issued, we got three or four responses. One of them was way out of our price range (we budgeted around $60,000 for the project, and I believe one of the responses came in around $250,000). Another wanted to charge us around $75,000 to install a free, open-source project on our server.

We were interested in two of the response we got to that RFP.

However, when I went to check the references for those two vendors, I got the equivalent of blank stares (or whatever you get over the telephone and through e-mail) when I asked about the vendors responding to our RFP. Both vendors had provided references for the software they were planning to install; not for their companies. For one of the companies, none of the five references I checked had ever even heard of the company. For the other company, only about half had actually worked with the vendor that responded.

For the first company, that was the death knell. For the other company, who was actually the official worldwide distributor of the product, we decided to take a chance. We were impressed by the system and looked forward to working with the company. Unfortunately, over the time we were evaluating the proposal and the product, the vendor with whom we were working split from the company that developed the CMS. When it came time to sign any proposals, it got really confusing. Some of the paperwork had one company's name, some of the paperwork had the other company's name. Although company A had been the one to respond to our RFP, they wanted us to sign a contract with company B (which, at least in our state, is against the procurement regulations). We ended up having to drop them altogether and reissue the RFP.

I went through and modified the RFP again and we reissued it. However, at this same time, I started developing a CMS on my own. We hired an assistant to handle my day-to-day responsibilities while I focused entirely on development of the CMS. We ended up with a great product that was tailored specifically to our needs.
Hi Rebecca,

We've been using Drupal for about 3 years now and by and large are happy with it. We've written up a case study (somewhat out of date now but still informative) on what we built and how we use it here:

http://groups.drupal.org/node/10231

The main thing I'd stress if you're looking at Drupal is that you need to be staffed appropriately to get the most out of it, with at least one competent developer dedicated to building on top of it.

You can use Drupal as a turnkey solution with no development staff but it offers less upside relative to other products when used that way...though partnering with Acquia could help with that equation.
David,

Thanks for posting that link. I've been working with Drupal for a few weeks (after years on Typo3) and I've been struggling with Drupal's weird (to me) organization. Plus I don't mind seeing how Amherst does cool stuff.

On a completely unrelated note... Hastings doesn't seem to have the purple ballcap with the white A on it anymore... is there a store on campus that carries that stuff?
Sure thing on the links to our drupal stuff. As to Hastings...that's odd, I bought one from there within the last year as a gift. There's no on-campus store, Hastings is the official unofficial campus store so to speak - perhaps they were just out of stock would be my best guess.
Hi Rebecca,

I had a chance to try out Hannon Hill's Cascade CMS. As a developer, my response can be summed up as "I really don't want to use this." The user interface wasn't intuitive and the simplest tasks required an inordinate amount of settings, files, and clicks to accomplish.

I'm not familiar with any of the other groups. Unfortunately my campus never had a chance to try out anything from OmniUpdate, but after a strong recommendation from Rachel I got in touch with one of their people. He sent me some info. Based on my positive interaction with him and the brief overview of the CMS in the materials supplied I think OmniUpdate is a strong choice worth investigating.
We use Cascade Server at Brandeis and overall it seems fine for our Web editors. It's hard to fine any product that is great for all level of users. I agree that I personally may get frustrated using it, but then I'd rather just use emacs :)

If anyone has questions about running Cascade Server, just let me know. To give an idea of scope, we have nearly 600 registered web editors and about 100k publishable files coming from the CMS. There are still some sites that have yet to be migrated into the CMS, but this speaks more to changes in design and re-architecture than about any specific product.

RSS

Elsewhere

Latest Activity

Erin Leavitt commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Today's blog post sums up the Higher Ed Live Special Edition broadcast, “The Catalog to End All Catalogs,” with Nathan Gerber from Utah Valley University and Dawn Truelsen from Fresno State. Get the scoop! "
yesterday
Marj Esch is now a member of University Web Developers
yesterday
Erin Leavitt commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"This Friday May 8 at 10 am PT Higher Ed Live will present "Communication United: Social Media and Your Website" featuring Elizabethtown College and Pepperdine University. Mark your calendars!  "
Monday
Erin Leavitt commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Miss out on your chance to take advantage of Table Transformations in OU Campus? We've got you covered! Watch the latest Training Tuesday now."
Friday
Katie Ryan Lambert posted a discussion

Website Redesign - Change Management & Communications

In a few months, my organization is rolling out a new Intranet for a many campuses and a central location with a new look and feel and new technology (moving from Oracle Portal to Microsoft SharePoint). The site is used by campus research administration staff to get the information and single-sign on access to tools & applications they need to do their jobs.I've managed several technology roll-outs and upgrade and know how users can have strong reactions to change. (I was here in 2006 when…See More
Apr 30
Erin Leavitt commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Jim Heiney from Lock Haven University gives a humorous and informative explanation of the OU Campus _resources folders in today's blog post  "
Apr 29
Profile IconJose Pedraza and D Simone joined University Web Developers
Apr 27
Erin Leavitt commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"We’re so happy to welcome Washington State Board for Community & Technical Colleges to the OmniUpdate family!"
Apr 24
Ken Pooley replied to Ken Pooley's discussion Examples of landing pages in Higher Ed
"Good question....having spent a little time, between stops in highered, in a business which was pretty cut throat competitive and really leveraged direct response marketing and jailed landing pages at a high level, I have been surprised how little…"
Apr 22
Erin Leavitt commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"When 404 happens, what do your visitors see? Find out how some of your higher ed peers are keeping visitors on their website in today's blog post! "
Apr 22
Florentin Albu posted discussions
Apr 21
Profile IconFlorentin Albu and Ashley Banks joined University Web Developers
Apr 21
Rachel Carden posted a discussion

Speakers needed for HighEdWeb Alabama conference - Deadline is Friday, April 24

You have great ideas. The HighEdWeb Alabama conference is looking for great ideas! Please consider sharing your great ideas with HighEdWeb Alabama! Our call for speakers is open until Friday!Share You Brain With Us!We all think and work differently. Whether you realize it or not, you have unique insight, skills, and expertise that others have not experienced. We want to hear about your projects and your strategy. We want you to share your brain…See More
Apr 20
Chris Paddock replied to Ken Pooley's discussion Examples of landing pages in Higher Ed
"Hi Ken,  Can I ask, are you trying to get better perspective on the experience, construction, something else? Just curious.  Chris "
Apr 20
Erin Leavitt commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"What exactly is a well-composed picture when it comes to your website? Marie Wise from Lower Columbia College has the answer! Why You Want Pictures on Your Web Pages (Part 2) "
Apr 14
Erin Leavitt commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Learn about the 2015 OmniUpdate Hackathon from the ‪#‎OU15Hackathon‬ participants themselves in this blog post! "
Apr 10
Kris Read is now a member of University Web Developers
Apr 10
Erin Leavitt commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"OU Campus Users: Get the 2015 OmniUpdate User Training Conference presentation slides, photos, and videos now on the OmniUpdate Community Network! Don't miss Lance Merker's opening, "The Key to Web Success: Leveraging the Power of the…"
Apr 9
Erin Leavitt commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Another enlightening post by Marie Wise from Lower Columbia College on the importance of pictures on your higher ed‬ website! Read it now."
Apr 8
Erin Leavitt commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Honored to have Kodiak College join our OU Campus users. 50,000 and counting!"
Apr 6

UWEBD has been in existence for more than 10 years and is the very best email discussion list on the Internet, in any industry, on any topic

About

© 2015   Created by Mark Greenfield.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service