University Web Developers

University Web Developers

Hi all,

I need feedback on your institution's experience with the following CMS vendors:

* Day
* Ektron
* Sitecore
* Hannon Hill
* Fatwire

And/or your experience with these open source CMS products:

* Drupal
* TYPO3

Also do you have any experience with a support contract for Drupal or TYPO3, such
as from Acquia.com or Acqal.com?

And last:

Do you have any general tips on particularly outstanding or awful enterprise-level content management products?

Thank you for your time!

Rebecca

Tags: CMS, Content, Management, Systems

Views: 123

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

We built a CMS and have been supporting it since 2002. I constantly weight the pros/cons of starting fresh with a new CMS or building off the current one. Interesting to see what comes up in this conversation!
Hey Rebecca! Curious why you're not evaluating OmniUpdate? We've been a client for 4+ years here at SUNY New Paltz, and they have a killer New York State contract that saved us oodles of money.
Hey Rachel!

I would have loved to evaluate it, however they did not respond to our bid. I had no idea they had a NYS contract and will pass that along to our CMS team. Thank you so much for the info!

So are you happy with them?

Rebecca
I've been incredibly happy with them -- but more importantly, my end users love the product. I'd be happy to put you in touch with Michael Monina, their VP of Sales & our SUNY/NY rep.
That would be great Rachel!

And if any of you have comments on any of the other vendors I mentioned, I would appreciate the feedback on those as well.

Rebecca
Rebecca,

I took a quick look at the contract (on the ITEC site) and it appears to be a hosted version. Don't know if that's a factor.
I won't use any specific names of companies or vendors, but I will share some of our experiences in searching for a CMS. In the end, we ended up developing our own CMS because it was so difficult to get exactly what we wanted.

We issued an RFP a total of three times. The first RFP we issued, I believe we got 0 responses (that was before I was hired). The second RFP we issued, we got three or four responses. One of them was way out of our price range (we budgeted around $60,000 for the project, and I believe one of the responses came in around $250,000). Another wanted to charge us around $75,000 to install a free, open-source project on our server.

We were interested in two of the response we got to that RFP.

However, when I went to check the references for those two vendors, I got the equivalent of blank stares (or whatever you get over the telephone and through e-mail) when I asked about the vendors responding to our RFP. Both vendors had provided references for the software they were planning to install; not for their companies. For one of the companies, none of the five references I checked had ever even heard of the company. For the other company, only about half had actually worked with the vendor that responded.

For the first company, that was the death knell. For the other company, who was actually the official worldwide distributor of the product, we decided to take a chance. We were impressed by the system and looked forward to working with the company. Unfortunately, over the time we were evaluating the proposal and the product, the vendor with whom we were working split from the company that developed the CMS. When it came time to sign any proposals, it got really confusing. Some of the paperwork had one company's name, some of the paperwork had the other company's name. Although company A had been the one to respond to our RFP, they wanted us to sign a contract with company B (which, at least in our state, is against the procurement regulations). We ended up having to drop them altogether and reissue the RFP.

I went through and modified the RFP again and we reissued it. However, at this same time, I started developing a CMS on my own. We hired an assistant to handle my day-to-day responsibilities while I focused entirely on development of the CMS. We ended up with a great product that was tailored specifically to our needs.
Hi Rebecca,

We've been using Drupal for about 3 years now and by and large are happy with it. We've written up a case study (somewhat out of date now but still informative) on what we built and how we use it here:

http://groups.drupal.org/node/10231

The main thing I'd stress if you're looking at Drupal is that you need to be staffed appropriately to get the most out of it, with at least one competent developer dedicated to building on top of it.

You can use Drupal as a turnkey solution with no development staff but it offers less upside relative to other products when used that way...though partnering with Acquia could help with that equation.
David,

Thanks for posting that link. I've been working with Drupal for a few weeks (after years on Typo3) and I've been struggling with Drupal's weird (to me) organization. Plus I don't mind seeing how Amherst does cool stuff.

On a completely unrelated note... Hastings doesn't seem to have the purple ballcap with the white A on it anymore... is there a store on campus that carries that stuff?
Sure thing on the links to our drupal stuff. As to Hastings...that's odd, I bought one from there within the last year as a gift. There's no on-campus store, Hastings is the official unofficial campus store so to speak - perhaps they were just out of stock would be my best guess.
Hi Rebecca,

I had a chance to try out Hannon Hill's Cascade CMS. As a developer, my response can be summed up as "I really don't want to use this." The user interface wasn't intuitive and the simplest tasks required an inordinate amount of settings, files, and clicks to accomplish.

I'm not familiar with any of the other groups. Unfortunately my campus never had a chance to try out anything from OmniUpdate, but after a strong recommendation from Rachel I got in touch with one of their people. He sent me some info. Based on my positive interaction with him and the brief overview of the CMS in the materials supplied I think OmniUpdate is a strong choice worth investigating.
We use Cascade Server at Brandeis and overall it seems fine for our Web editors. It's hard to fine any product that is great for all level of users. I agree that I personally may get frustrated using it, but then I'd rather just use emacs :)

If anyone has questions about running Cascade Server, just let me know. To give an idea of scope, we have nearly 600 registered web editors and about 100k publishable files coming from the CMS. There are still some sites that have yet to be migrated into the CMS, but this speaks more to changes in design and re-architecture than about any specific product.

RSS

Elsewhere

Latest Activity

Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Have you seen The University of South Alabama's new online course catalog? It integrates with Banner. Looks sharp! Check it out. "
yesterday
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Congrats to Oklahoma City Community College on going live with their new responsive online course catalog! "
Monday
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Curious about what's going to be in the 2015 E-Expectations Report? Get some hints in today's blog post! "
Aug 20
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Big congrats to Butler County Community College on going live in OU Campus last week with their new responsive site. Looks amazing! Check it out: bc3.edu "
Aug 20
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"HUGE shout-out to Hope College on going live in OU Campus with their new responsive site, which Includes a course catalog, calendar, directories, news center, and much more! Check it out: hope.edu "
Aug 18
Howard Hanna posted a discussion

Cloud Providers: Acquia or Pantheon?

We're considering moving a lower-trafficked site with a fairly vanilla Drupal install to a cloud provider and are wondering whether to go with Acquia or Pantheon.Which would you choose?See More
Aug 18
Profile IconJanine Sazinsky and Cynthia Rodriguez joined University Web Developers
Aug 14
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"#OUTC16 dates and location have been announced!! Get the scoop on our blog! "
Aug 13
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Southwest Mississippi Community College has joined the OmniUpdate family. Hip hip hooray!! #weloveourcustomers‬"
Aug 11
Howard Hanna posted a discussion

Site Search: Evaluating and Testing

Amherst College is considering switching the search engine we use on our website (Drupal) from Google Search Appliance (GSA) to Google Custom Search Engine (CSE). We are considering using Google Tag Manager (GTM) for A/B testing of GSA and CSE. We are configured to seamlessly switch between the two search options.Does anyone have ideas, resources, or a checklist you've used for testing the site search and gauging relevancy?If not GTM for A/B testing, any recommendation on what else to use?All…See More
Aug 5
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"New post up on the blog by OmniUpdate CEO, Lance Merker! Check it out: Three Takeaways from #eduweb15 "
Aug 4
Phyllis Treige posted a discussion

UX Analyst at University of Wisconsin-Madison

The Communications Department in the UW-Madison Division of Information Technology (DoIT) is looking for a full-time User Experience Analyst to join our team.  The opportunityWe’re redefining the experience of higher education at UW-Madison, from improving the course enrollment process to designing tools that support advising to overhauling the MyUW portal.  We need someone who is driven to understand the challenges our users face, to help untangle thorny process and technical ecosystems, and…See More
Aug 4
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"We're so excited to add Lake Tahoe Community College to the OmniUpdate family! Welcome aboard!"
Aug 3
Profile IconKendra Smith, Dan LeGate, Matt Kacskos and 2 more joined University Web Developers
Jul 31
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Congrats to Snow College on going live in OU Campus with their new responsive site! Check it out: www.snow.edu "
Jul 30
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Get the scoop on snippets in the new post up on the blog! "
Jul 29
Erin Leavitt commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"New blog post from Kate Browne, Technology Trainer at Illinois Wesleyan University! The Welcoming Website Part 1: Accessibility and Universal Design "
Jul 22
Erin Leavitt commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Nevada State College went live in our OU Campus CMS! Check it out: nsc.edu http://nsc.edu/"
Jul 20
Erin Leavitt commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Exciting news! We've released 10.3 of OU Campus which includes OU Marketplace! Read all about it in today's blog post. "
Jul 17
Erin Leavitt commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Bard College at Simon's Rock's website has a great new look! New design by Lipman Hearne. Check it out: simons-rock.edu "
Jul 14

UWEBD has been in existence for more than 10 years and is the very best email discussion list on the Internet, in any industry, on any topic

About

© 2015   Created by Mark Greenfield.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service