University Web Developers

University Web Developers

If we adopt a CMS, what else should we have in place before choosing one, assuming we should have one at all? What kind of problems will it not solve for us? I am with a small private college (under a thousand students) with limited human and financial resources. Most of our staff and faculty are 50ish, and not Web-savvy.

Our current website is built and maintained in the traditional way with Dreamweaver. We want to empower people to create their own content, and I wonder if there is some way other than a CMS so that they can have the basic necessary permissions to do so.

I'd love to hear from anyone who has been through this decision making process or could point me in the direction of how to find out more about how to create such a process.

Views: 516

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

A CMS comes with its own grab bag of problems to consider. You'll have to have individual departments determine who is responsible for maintaining their content, and make sure they're in charge of it (put it in their job descriptions). Then you'll have to train them. And that means training them over, and over and over, because many of them will only touch the CMS once per semester, and then they'll forget. You'll have to train them to use the thing, but also train them to write good web copy; train them to not use animated gifs and make everything purple and bold; train them that there is a right and wrong time to use the school colors and that "creativity" is not the enemy of consistency, but that subtlety is creativity's best friend.

And when you've done all that, then you'll still have to spend a bunch of your time auditing the changes they've made.

 

CMSs are also fairly complex, so if external hosting isn't your cup of tea, you'll need to make sure you have adequate in-house support. I don't have statistics, but I have no doubt CMSs play a significant role in website outages when they're on the front lines without adequate support.

 

That's all I got for now -- if you want to discuss this in depth, I'd be happy to help.

 

-Mike

Mike Smith,

Thanks so much for your help and your offer of more. One other human resource issue that concerns me is, job description or not, I think many department heads will use their people in ways they consider more crucial than supporting their websites. Not only because they are short of staff, but because their focus and their skills are not in creating and maintaining web content. So, I wonder how it would work if we assigned support people to work with those departments but they are under the supervision of the chief web officer. Then they would do this work regularly, not just once a semester, and the training could be better used. What do you think?

I'm always ancy about changing people's roles, even in a controlled way. There will probably be some organizational discomfort no matter how you do it, but it's bound to be better than having one team or person responsible for all the edits on a 900 page site.

A CMS is essential for any website bigger than a 4-5 pages. And there are all sorts of options, both local and hosted, WordPress and Sharepoint are both CMSs. Plus there are free open source options like Drupal and Joomla. And many, many fine higher-ed only choices, we use Ingeniux. Also, you can do quite a bit internally with some php and mysql code.

I would look to a CMS first and foremost to streamline your process, and look to bring users in later.

Good luck, I am happy to chat with you anytime!

Michael Santoroski,

Thanks much for your reply. Well, our website is a lot more than 4-5 pages; I alone manage more like 900.

How will a CMS 'streamline my process'? If anything, I see obstacles to such tasks with a CMS. For example, I can do search-and-replace across static web pages, but how is that done with CMS articles?

It depends on your CMS. For example, in our CMS, Plone, a global search is trivial, but a search-and-replace on the editable part of articles would require an experienced Python developer to step into the back-end. On the other hand, it's never happened, because there isn't much repetition on that part of the site. The CMS allows users to replicate content across site hierarchies (so down entire branches) so it only need to be changed in one place.

But that's a great specific point to keep on your requirements document as you search for a CMS.

Seriously, this is a Michael heavy thread!

I just caught this:

I wonder if there is some way other than a CMS so that they can have the basic necessary permissions to do so.

Please do not get tempted by Adobe Contribute. It may sound like exactly what you're seeking, but it will not make your life easier. We switched from Contribute two years ago after a painful three years with it. If you find yourself considering a distributed CMS like this, ask me for a list of reasons why you should avoid that style of content management.

THIS
I second this.

This. A billion times this.

 

-- SUNY-ESF's Contribute admin here...

I got into higher edu web development back in 2010. We had Contribute when I arrived and it gave us more than a few headaches. We got away from it earlier this year.

RSS

Elsewhere

Latest Activity

Lauren Zakich commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Jim Heiney from Lock Haven University shares his advice on how an editorial calendar can help keep your web content up to date and engaging in today’s blog post.  "
Thursday
Lauren Zakich commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"We have a new addition to our OmniUpdate family. Welcome, Cerritos College! "
Wednesday
Lauren Zakich commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Emergency Alerts for OU Campus allows you to communicate with students, staff, and the community with custom website announcements. When time matters most, make sure your website is the go-to place for info."
Tuesday
Neil Joellenbeck replied to Mark Greenfield's discussion The Future of the UWEBD Social Network
"This is the first time I have been here in a long time. Selfishly, I would hope that you would be able to continue the site, but I understand realities. As I re-acquaint myself, I'm seeing a lot of value in what you have tirelessly built.…"
Sep 16
Gareth J M Saunders replied to Mark Greenfield's discussion The Future of the UWEBD Social Network
"Hi Mark, in line with many others who have posted, first a big thank you for providing this resource for so many years. I was a keen reader of it and occasional poster a good few years ago. And I loved my Website Hero mug until I dropped it and had…"
Sep 15
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Have you heard about our new UX Feedback Program? Your input can directly affect the future of OU Campus! Learn more in today's blog post. "
Sep 14
Lauren Zakich joined Lynn Zawie's group
Thumbnail

OmniUpdate

Share your experiences using OmniUpdate CMS
Sep 13
Genevieve Howard replied to Mark Greenfield's discussion The Future of the UWEBD Social Network
"I want to chime in along with the others in thanking you for being a leader in our niche group! I appreciate your effort. I lean toward LinkedIn. "
Sep 13
A. Watson replied to Mark Greenfield's discussion The Future of the UWEBD Social Network
"I was a recent addition and did not find too much activity here that I could leverage but LinkedIn does seem to be the logical destination.  Perhaps there is interest here and you can crowd source the migration. Migrating the content could…"
Sep 13
Eloine Chapman replied to Mark Greenfield's discussion The Future of the UWEBD Social Network
"I would be very sorry to see this resource go. I am just a one person shop at my college and feel quite a alone as far as anyone understanding the complexity of what I do. It's a wonderful thing to see people facing the same challenges I face…"
Sep 13
Christopher Spires replied to Mark Greenfield's discussion The Future of the UWEBD Social Network
"I wouldn't feel necessary to stick with Ning if the cost isn't a burden. Facebook, LinkedIn, and Slack are all satisfactory options in my opinion. Slack is a great option for more instant communication, and you'll probably find a lot…"
Sep 13
Mark Lawrence replied to Mark Greenfield's discussion The Future of the UWEBD Social Network
"Thank you Mark, this has been an invaluable resource - particularly for seeing how our cohorts at other institutions approach the problems we all face. But, as many people have said today, I haven't visited in a while. I think that's…"
Sep 13
Charlie Lindahl replied to Mark Greenfield's discussion The Future of the UWEBD Social Network
"Ah. Thank you. I've just sent a request to have TAMU.EDU added to the list."
Sep 13
Laurie Trow replied to Mark Greenfield's discussion The Future of the UWEBD Social Network
"Is this for the Slack? If so, you need to email leta@berkeley.edu to have your edu domain added."
Sep 13
Hugh Jarvis replied to Mark Greenfield's discussion The Future of the UWEBD Social Network
"Regardless of where this goes, Mark, thanks for setting it up and running it all these years! I find it quite useful myself, lurking mostly, but occasionally joining in where it might help us, or I might be able to provide value. I like having this…"
Sep 13
Charlie Lindahl replied to Mark Greenfield's discussion The Future of the UWEBD Social Network
"OK, I give up. I am at Texas A&M, and @tamu.edu is not listed among those allowed to create userids. Can someone either (1) add TAMU.EDU or (2) send me an invitation to uwebd slack? (clindahl@tamhsc.edu). Thanks, Charlie"
Sep 13
Jay Massey replied to Mark Greenfield's discussion The Future of the UWEBD Social Network
"Mark, I agree that the paid Ning site may have outlived its usefulness in light of other group media apps. Like many have stated, Slack and FaceBook / LinkedIn groups. are good options. Slack may not have as much adoption as FB or LI yet. Consider…"
Sep 13
David P. Dillard replied to Mark Greenfield's discussion The Future of the UWEBD Social Network
"If you decide to leave Ning, please consider as an additional place to have this discussion group at no cost, the GROUPS.IO discussion group network which is free and of a very high quality. It also provides a wiki to those who have discussion…"
Sep 13
Tiffany Broadbent replied to Mark Greenfield's discussion The Future of the UWEBD Social Network
"There is already a uwebd.slack.com Slack group that was created back in May so that is something that folks could transition to now if they'd like (http://cuwebd.ning.com/forum/topics/is-there-a-university-web-developers-slack-group). I…"
Sep 13
Sherrie Roberts replied to Mark Greenfield's discussion The Future of the UWEBD Social Network
"UWEBD is a site I come to ever so often but would hate for it to go away because it is a great place to meet and get input from other university web developers. Maybe move to a cheaper platform, Facebook group or LinkedIn group would be my choices.…"
Sep 13

UWEBD has been in existence for more than 10 years and is the very best email discussion list on the Internet, in any industry, on any topic

About

© 2016   Created by Mark Greenfield.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service