University Web Developers

University Web Developers

Vertical vs Horizontal Global Navigation (any usability studies?)

Are there any case studies or data on the usability of vertical navigation on higher education websites? I'm referring to vertical global navigation, which would also include vertical navigation for lower level sites. 

The only references I came across (not specific to higher ed) are this article http://www.smashingmagazine.com/2010/01/11/the-case-against-vertica... and this blog post - http://www.usefulusability.com/main-navigation-types-and-usability-.... Is there more definitive information out there? I'm trying to build a case against going with a new site design that features vertical navigation.

The biggest drawback I see for implementing vertical global navigation is poor usability. Given the large amount of content typically found on a higher ed sites, need to serve multiple audiences, many lower level pages I think it's hard to navigate sites with vertical nav. As you get deeper into lower level department sites the navigation tends to extend further down the page which might force you to scroll up or down on the page to access the page content or links in the vertical navigation. 

Appreciate any thoughts or suggestions.

Thanks,

Doug

Views: 2036

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I'll look forward to answers as they come in on this one- we have both horizontal and vertical nav...........

Thanks Sarah. Just to clarify, I'm talking about just a vertical navigation for global nav and subsite nav. My feeling is that most visitors to higher ed sites are use to a IA convention of having a horizontal global primary nav and then a vertical subsite navigation once you get level pages off the homepage, e.g., Admission, Academics, Campus Life, and vertical nav for lower level department pages.

Hope this makes sense. There are sites out there that use an entirely vertical navigation (with no horizontal nav for global nav links) so I'm looking for any usability data that takes about the pros and cons of this approach.

Thanks,

Doug

HMM. I see. Yes, we have a vertical nav on our homepage currently, but its not global and we are actually looking to remove it now. If I run across any global-level usability stuff in my travels, I'll know where to post it!

I don't know of any specific studies, but I agree that the majority of higher ed sites use horizontal primary and vertical secondary navs. This is something I've been thinking a lot about lately as we update our core templates to build in responsive features. I don't think a combined global and secondary vertical nav would work well. Depending on the design it could be too much to scan and gets in the way of valuable real estate.

Our global nav is horizontal and is featured on every single page. Individual sites, such as this one,  have a title bar, and then their own primary horizontal nav below it. Within each main section, or tab, there is a vertical nav which can support up to two levels. I have sometimes wondered if having two horizontal navs would be confusing, but so far informal and anecdotal data shows that it works fairly well. I'm also working to remove dropdown/flyout menus across the board because in a lot of cases its overkill, and is hard to use on mobile/touch devices.

tl;dr - a vertical global nav for the whole site doesn't make much sense IMHO. I think a horizontal layout, combined with a visual tab metaphor, is the way to go.

RSS

Elsewhere

Latest Activity

Scott Knauer is now a member of University Web Developers
yesterday
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Get the story behind our newest module OU Alerts and how our customers are helping shape its future in today's blog post! "
Wednesday
Vivek G. Bharathan is now a member of University Web Developers
Tuesday
Marc Boman joined Paul Branham's group
Thumbnail

Community Colleges

Discussions and such pertaining to the unique situations that present themselves to Community Colleges.
Monday
Marc Boman joined Mark Greenfield's group
Monday
Dan Demmons posted a discussion

SVA - anyone using this for their marketing campaigns

Hello everyone,I'm wondering if anyone is using SVA to help assist with their marketing efforts? Brief info on what SVA is - http://www.carnegiecomm.com/blog/non-traditional-student-audiences-cant-find-them-build-them/Here's a company that provides assistance with incorporating SVA- http://www.semcasting.com/I've a…See More
Jun 16
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Looking for the secrets to success for a website redesign? Check out our latest blog post for some great tips! "
Jun 15
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"We are excited to welcome West Chester University to the OmniUpdate family! "
Jun 14
Justin Farrow shared their photo on Facebook
Jun 13
Justin Farrow posted a photo
Jun 13
Profile IconJustin Farrow and oscar pineda joined University Web Developers
Jun 13
Jeffrey Green replied to Dan Demmons's discussion Anyone know what happened to www.edustyle.net
"Looks like they shut it down and started a consultancy?"
Jun 9
Megan Kowalski is now a member of University Web Developers
Jun 8
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Check out today’s blog post to learn how Farmingdale State College used Google Analytics and contact form inquiries to guide their website redesign. "
Jun 7
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Drumroll… the winner of our 2016 OmniUpdate Gadget Challenge is Eric Odom from Augusta University with his Readability Gadget! Congrats Eric, you’ve earned free registration to #OUTC17!!"
Jun 7
Profile IconAlisa Robakowski, Mark Rogers, Charise Alexander Adams and 1 more joined University Web Developers
Jun 7
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"It’s Module Monday! This month we’re featuring our course catalog. See it in action! "
Jun 6
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Extending a very warm welcome to our newest customer, SUNY Clinton Community College! "
Jun 3
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"How did Clarion University’s website become a “20-year overnight success” based on a string of bad ideas? Get the scoop in today’s blog post! "
Jun 1
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Don't forget, today is the LAST DAY to vote in the 2016 OmniUpdate Gadget Challenge. Vote now!"
May 31

UWEBD has been in existence for more than 10 years and is the very best email discussion list on the Internet, in any industry, on any topic

About

© 2016   Created by Mark Greenfield.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service