University Web Developers

University Web Developers

So, for no particular reason, is anyone currently/have experience using Joomla, TYPO3 or WebGUI for their college's wCMS? And would be willing to answer a few questions?  I'd appreciate your time and feedback greatly.

Many thanks,

Colleen

Views: 733

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I don't know much anything about WebGUI. Typo3 is the perfect solution if you hate your users with the fire of 1,000 suns. Joomla if you just need the fire of a single sun.

Ok, let's back up and examine the 1000 suns issue. What in Typo3 was problematic for users (besides "everything")? Was it UI? Workflow permissions? Integrations with templates and styles? Any info is very helpful since it's on a short(er) list right now.

When last I evaluated Typo3 (admittedly not real recently), I found it to be EXTREMELY powerful. However, it was a CMS built by programmers, for programmers, with no consideration whatsoever for unskilled users. There wasn't a user on campus I could name that I would have felt comfortable setting loose in the back end to set up and maintain a site. The UI was heavily data-centric, with little context for how it would be used when published. It was painful to navigate, and ultimately confusing to administer. Joomla had a slightly better UX, but suffered similarly in the "designed by programmers" regard (check out the plugin architecture, for instance - or the way templating and menus work).

Honestly, if you're set on open source, check out dotCMS, Reason, Wordpress (depending on the use case), Drupal (if you can commit support resources), Magnolia, or recently - Big Tree CMS (they are newly enterprise open source, damn curious to have someone look at them closer). 

Great feedback, Fienen -- thanks. We are indeed set on open-source and looked at most of those you mentioned ... Wordpress isn't going to work for us for a variety of reasons, and Drupal is out because of exactly what you cited -- we'll have resources to commit but frankly not as many as Drupal will need from us.

If we reopen the list, dotCMS is one I'll look at again ... haven't heard of BigTree but I'll bring it to the working group.

I haven't used Joomla in probably 6 or 7 years, but if you are seriously looking at it, you're probably going to need to completely rethink the way you envision the architecture of your site. Within Joomla, there are no concepts of parent and child pages; instead, the entire site's architecture relies on which menu you place on each page. That was a deep-seated problem in the original Mambo core that all of Joomla's developers said was impossible to change.

My favorite was how a page's template could change based on what menu you used to get to it - a behavior far more maddening than it was novel and useful.

I also have recollections of murdering puppies while trying to build templates for it.

Yeah, that was definitely the most frustrating thing about using Joomla. I am so glad I didn't stick with it for long.

I used Typo3 with a freelance client a few years back. There we only a few people in the organization and I put together a very minimal 'manual' for them on frequent practices (create/edit content, upload images, etc). The biggest challenge I recall was trying to understand the scripting system for templates and menus. I've been using Drupal for a number of years for other projects.

I haven't found any of the open source CMSes particularly friendly from the 'average user' perspective, particularly when they abstract content away from the 'page' model. Most departmental web maintainers are used to traditional HTML tools (Dreamweaver, Contribute, etc) and think in terms of pages and folders. When you ask them to grapple a more programmer-friendly model (where pages turn into content types/data), expect significant training requirements. And, if the CMS doesn't have a view of the site that's consistent with their prior experience (pages within folders, being able to edit content directly on a page), it further contributes to the confusion.

For what it's worth, I've been working with CMS-based websites in higher ed since 1999, starting with a commercial CMS. In my current environment, we have a commercial CMS that, to a certain extent, supports the folder/page model while offering the benefits of abstraction.

Any CMS is going to require at least one dedicated programmer. You'll also need a helpdesk.

I've used Joomla since 2004 (Mambo at the time) and have deployed nearly 200 sites with it. I built it to support about 100 unskilled content contributors (from secretaries to faculty to student workers) and most were quite happy with it. The current version (2.5.x) is the best so far. I'd be happy to answer any other questions you had about it... I simply love it! (I do have Wordpress sites too.)

RSS

Elsewhere

Latest Activity

Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Web governance should not be an afterthought; when it’s done right, it can actually enhance your workflow and make your job easier. http://bit.ly/33vIZU0"
Nov 8
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Exciting news... OmniUpdate has merged with Destiny Solutions! Learn more on our blog. http://bit.ly/332KSr8"
Oct 30
Linda Faciana commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Switching to a new CMS? Join our next webcast with Briana Johnson from @OSUIT to learn how to convince decentralized web content authors to tolerate the switch, actively participate, and enjoy it! http://bit.ly/2zhdcIt"
Oct 29
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Your website is the front door to your college or university. Your website design has to accommodate for the way that students interact with and use the information your institution provides. http://bit.ly/2P8VldR"
Oct 24
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Learn how a new website design and CMS helped Florida Gulf Coast University increase new visits to the school’s website with improved SEO. http://bit.ly/2ByaQq4"
Oct 21
Profile IconJames Pollard and Michael Clarke joined University Web Developers
Oct 21
Linda Faciana commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Join our next webcast with Kelly Rushing from @uofsouthalabama to learn how to create accessible PDFs for your website by starting with your source documents. http://bit.ly/2zhdcIt"
Oct 18
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Learn why your college or university should choose SaaS across the board, especially for your next CMS. http://bit.ly/2Iy0SZE"
Oct 8
Linda Faciana commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Join us for our next webcast with OmniUpdate CEO Lance Merker, who will delve into key insights about Generation Z’s online search behaviors to help you refine your school's web marketing strategy. http://bit.ly/2zhdcIt"
Oct 3
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Our newest guide will help you learn what it means to be accessible, how to implement accessibility best practices, quick fixes to try as well as a long-term plan, plus tools to help you in your website accessibility efforts. Download it now!"
Oct 1
Linda Faciana commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Are online forms more efficient? Learn how El Camino College used Formstack to create online forms that expedited processing, improved communications, increased transparency, and promoted accountability across campus. http://bit.ly/2zhdcIt"
Sep 18
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"It's important to understand the science behind your web pages to better engage and ultimately attract prospective students to your site. http://bit.ly/2ZYK8FZ"
Sep 12
Linda Faciana commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"If you’re struggling with web challenges such as accessibility, SEO, design consistency, workflow, content governance, or how to start a website redesign, you’re not alone. Join our next webcast to learn how other higher ed institutions…"
Sep 5
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"eQAfy confirms that OU Campus is still the #1 commercial CMS for colleges and universities in the United States. http://bit.ly/2Lir9Mn"
Aug 28
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Here’s an outline of everything you need to know about OCR compliance, including what it is, what your college or university can do to stay compliant, and resources for OCR compliance. #accessibility http://bit.ly/2rcPDgG"
Aug 23
Linda Faciana commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Join us for our next webcast with April Buscher from Montana State University Billings to learn how blind readers and people with hearing impairment view and read your website and how you can make it accessible to them. http://bit.ly/2zhdcIt"
Aug 14
Amanda Lawson joined Lynn Zawie's group
Thumbnail

OmniUpdate

Share your experiences using OmniUpdate CMS
Aug 9
Amanda Lawson posted a photo

Amanda Lawson

Amanda Lawson, Web Content ManagerCommunity College of Allgheny County
Aug 9
Sara Arnold commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"High schoolers spend more time on their digital devices than they do sleeping, doing homework, or participating in extracurricular activities. So how do you make your message stand out to them? #eexpect http://bit.ly/2MOIIWC"
Aug 8
Linda Faciana commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Want to increase digital engagement with high school juniors and seniors? Join our next webcast with Stephanie Geyer from Ruffalo Noel Levitz as she shares new data from the 2019 E-Expectations Trend Report on email, paid media, and social media…"
Jul 31

UWEBD has been in existence for more than 10 years and is the very best email discussion list on the Internet, in any industry, on any topic

About

© 2019   Created by Mark Greenfield.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service