University Web Developers

University Web Developers

Hi Folks-

Taking an informal poll about what CMS you are using and if you like it. Any feedback you can give us about what works and what doesn't would be helpful. 

Specifically we are looking information about Content Management Systems that offer:

-Responsive design

-Integration with the calendar software EMS

-Secure forms

-And one with good support services

Thank you

Views: 389

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Interesting question, and I'll kick off with the first open source option – there will no doubt be others put forward as well.

We are migrating from static HTML to WordPress.

  • Responsive. Check. 
  • EMS Integration... Sorta. (via RSS)
  • Secure forms. Check.
  • Good support services. Check (Easily contracted, as WordPress is a popular CMS.)

We are able to move away from the 'big iron' proprietary CMS vendors more easily than many institutions due to our relatively small scale (1200 students, 4700 pages under management.) and lack of lock-in to an existing vendor.

When I moved to university web work from the private sector, I was surprised to see that proprietary CMSs still dominate in the university market. I've come to understand that there are probably good organizational and historical reasons for that, though I expect to see many more institutions go open source over the next few years, with Drupal, WordPress, and possibly emerging cloud contenders increasingly seen as solid supportable alternatives.

While we've been using WordPress for two years, we will be cutting over our main web site to WordPress later this year. I'll share updates on the process and results here on uwebd.

Have been on Joomla 1.6 since god was a child, now moving ( probably) to Drupal. Wordpress was also considered pretty seriously, but there was more internal comfort with Drupal.

In terms of our reasoning:

  • Forms are part of the Drupal core, I have seen WP form plugins I thought were good, but they all tended to be proprietary.
  • There are a few large scale edu focused theme and module projects, that we may or may not use: OpenScholar, OpenAcademy and OpenFramework
  • Responsive is a function of theme, I am pushing hard for a bootstrap3 based theme.
  • Integration to other data sources is generally very doable.
  • Drupal community is great, if you want to kick up to commercial support Acquia is interesting and there are a few others, someone named SystemSeed has taken over development of OpenAcademy...which seems interesting.
  • While, at first blush, web stats seem to indicate that wordpress is the only CMS in the world, digging in to sites by TLD and traffic volume indicates a much more level field, in edu especially. While its not a popularity contest, we felt that indicated we would be able to find people to talk to and lots of examples of problem solving in our workspace. 

Hope that helps

Drupal has some strengths for larger sites, and has a strong a code-centric culture that seems to be a good fit for many universities looking at open source. I especially like the 'Types and Views' approach to displaying content chunks, which is very flexible. It is a common observation that WordPress appeals to writers, and than Drupal appeals to coders, and in general I find this to be true!

The 'gotchas' with Drupal are that a higher level of coding skill is often required to build and customize a particular feature, and that there is a tendency for busy developers to neglect the admin back-end, which really should be customized to make it friendlier for your writers and editors. I bet Drupal 8 will address some of these issues, as Drupal has a very strong and active development culture.

(BTW: I'm also a fan of Joomla for easy-to-build sites that can still have a good deal of navigational depth. Oddly, my perception is that Joomla seems stronger and better accepted in Latin America and Africa than here in North America and Europe, but that just may be my experience.)

We have been with OmniUpdate (OU Campus) since 2012. One of the reasons we chose OU: When I talked to universities about their CMS, in person or by phone, everyone who was with OU sounded happy. Really happy. And I feel the same.

The support services are top-notch. Our IT team is very small, and they rarely have to be consulted. Most tasks I can complete myself, and when I need OU's support, they are right on it.

To answer your other questions:

- Responsive design -- Yes, they can implement this, but you have to give them the HTML/CSS. We haven't brought our entire site into responsive, but we have one landing page template in OU that is responsive.

- Integration with EMS -- Probably, but I can't say for sure as we opted to use Bedework for our calendar database.

- Secure forms -- Yes.

Hope that helps!

RSS

Elsewhere

Latest Activity

Allison Howard is now a member of University Web Developers
Friday
Lauren Zakich commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Planning a dream kitchen is like redesigning a website. It's easy to change the colors, but if the content doesn't provide what users need, your site visitors will not find value. So where do you start?"
May 12
Lauren Zakich commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"When thinking about valuable content for your higher ed site, try testimonials and quotes to attract prospective students. Download the latest E-Expectations report today. "
May 11
Lauren Zakich commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Check out more of these stats by downloading our latest E-Expectations Report today!"
May 4
Lauren Zakich commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Your website’s voice helps drive your brand and deliver consistency across your site. In our latest blog post, Jim Heiney from Lock Haven University shows how to keep that consistency using OU Campus."
May 2
Fabio posted a discussion

Top 200 Universities in Facebook

Just a brief note to inform all University developers that we have just published a new ranking of the top 200 Universities in Facebook based on the number of likes (fans count) each Facebook page has. Visit http://www.4icu.org/top-universities-facebook/For the US listing of all Universities in Facebook and their fans count popularity please visit…See More
May 2
Lauren Zakich commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"New blog post! Find out what prospective students are wanting to find on your website."
Apr 28
Kathy Nix posted a discussion

user levels

Is there anyway you can edit a user level?  We have level 8 users and want to add "Add to Dictionary" without opening every user and clicking on the Add to Dictionary box.See More
Apr 26
Doug Thompson posted a discussion

Solution for deluge of daily emails?

So way back in "the day" (eight or so years ago), our employee/student email inboxes were routinely deluged with 40+ individual email messages per day due to the "campus-wide" email lists being open for anyone here to send messages to.Enough people eventually decried the situation, so we came up with an email/website "publication" that was basically akin to a "daily digest email" of what were originally individual messages.This was highly successful and took a large part of the burden off of…See More
Apr 21
Andrew Soderberg replied to Mark Greenfield's discussion The UWEBD Social Network Will Live On
"Mark, Just a suggestion regarding a sustainable future for UWEBD (software platform). When I was at OmniUpdate we migrated from Ning to SocialEngine. SE has a Ning 2 import tool: http://get.socialengine.com/ning/ The process was pretty smooth for…"
Apr 21
Christopher Snizik is now a member of University Web Developers
Apr 18
Lauren Zakich commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Our 2017 OmniUpdate User Training Conference was a huge success! For a recap of the event, head over to our blog. "
Apr 17
Profile IconChris Amelung and Derek Pasnick joined University Web Developers
Apr 10
Barb Iannucci replied to Dean Hartman's discussion Best CMS option
"I'm interested in this as well..."
Apr 4
Dean Hartman posted a discussion

Best CMS option

It's time for us to move away from our current CMS, and I was wondered what is working best for others: a pre-packaged solution, or building your own with WordPress, Drupal or ...?See More
Apr 4
Cindy is now a member of University Web Developers
Apr 1
Profile IconDean Hartman and Laura T joined University Web Developers
Mar 28
Tarekegn Nibret is now a member of University Web Developers
Mar 15
Scott Dailey is now a member of University Web Developers
Mar 10
Lauren Zakich commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Our presenters at the 2017 OmniUpdate User Training Conference are eager to share their wisdom! See a special announcement about our esteemed keynote speaker, and find out what our presenters are most excited to share in their sessions in our latest…"
Mar 8

UWEBD has been in existence for more than 10 years and is the very best email discussion list on the Internet, in any industry, on any topic

About

© 2017   Created by Mark Greenfield.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service