University Web Developers

University Web Developers

Disabling style-sheets? Does anyone know user(s) who actually do this?

As part of 508 check I have to disable style-sheets and check the layout of the page. I've run into a problem, and it made me start thinking about who it is that actually disables CSS. If you disable CSS in Firefox using the Accessibility Toolbar, then this will only disable CSS for the page you are on. Go to a new page and CSS is enabled again. Do users actually select to disable stylesheets for every page they go to? Perhaps, there is another way in which they permanently disable CSS? And do these users who have CSS disabled ever have Javascript enabled?

I'd really appreciate any answers in this regard, but didn't want to e-mail the list as I'd like to find a fix today.

Views: 1687

Replies to This Discussion

This page from WebAim does a good job of explaining the accessibility issues related to CSS:

http://www.webaim.org/techniques/css/
Thanks for the link, interesting stuff, but it doesn't really answer the question at all. I'm looking to see if there are actually any users out there who disable CSS. This is what the 508 guidelines say to do, disable CSS in order to check for accessibility, but do any users ever actually disable CSS? Maybe they customize it sure, but do they disable it?

If it helps, the reason for the question, is that I am using a JQuery plugin which produces errors if CSS is disabled, but I am fundamentally interested in whether or not anyone actually disables CSS as I have never seen a user do this or heard from the accessibility testers of a user who does this.
I disable css occasionally for a few reasons. 1- If the font is so small/bad that I can't read it, and zooming in destroys the layout. 2- To do a check (as a dev), which tells me the reading order of the page...

How?
In firefox, this is done by doing View > Page Style > no style. It stays like that in the tab but CSS is turned back on when a new tab opens. I bet you can override that if the user is savvy enough.
Ryan,

That is kind of my point, are we saying that disabled/accessibility needs users will have to disable their CSS each and every time they go to a new web page? This is why I have doubts that there is even such a user which always has CSS disabled (if that is even possible, I'm sure it probably is but so far haven't seen how).
The idea here is not that a disabled user will use a traditional browser with CSS turned off, but instead that some Assistive Technologies don't utilize CSS. By turning CSS off, you can get a better idea how these technologies wil work, especially with the concept of linearization. Another good testing method is using a text only browser like lynx.
Yes, I agree on the lynx idea, and do use it to test, but I guess I will need to find out from the accessibility committee or find some online source that lists these Assistive Technologies that don't utilize CSS, because if one of these tools disables all CSS, but also disables all Javascript then there is no point to trying to make a Javascript function work when CSS is disabled or vice-versa.
Mark,

Can you name an assistive technology that doesn't utilize CSS?

Which version of Firefox are you using for this to work?

Woops!  Ignore my reply.  Would help if I checked the date of the post.  I am joining a conversation that happened 4 years ago. :)

Name an assistive technology in use that doesn't use CSS.
For instance, any screen reader.

CSS does a ton of stuff, for instance, hiding, or otherwise controlling the position of content on a page. When it isn't rendered, the overall flow of a page can be altered dramatically, thus changing how something like a screen reader processes the page.

An example might be laying out a page in the following order: Navigation -> Body -> Header -> Footer
Then you use CSS to reorder things, like move the header to the top, and put the navigation after the body and float it right. How this page looks in a normal browser compared to a screen reader is significantly different.
I have gotten nothing but generic replies from this thread which is very disappointing, but what is even more disappointing is that you are either quite confused or just wrong on this matter.

The question is: Does anyone actually disable stylesheets?

Jaws, the screen reader I am most familiar with does not disable stylesheets. Check it out: http://www.freedomscientific.com/fs_support/BulletinView.asp?QC=1165

I ask a specific question and no one has answered it, which makes me believe that this 'test case' for 508 compliance testing doesn't actually exist.

RSS

Elsewhere

Latest Activity

Profile IconJulia Easton and KATE KWAME joined University Web Developers
Friday
Bill Hartley posted a discussion

Job Interview Presentation Ideas

Has anyone ever asked job candidates to do a presentation as part of the interview process? We're in the process of searching for a web director, and are looking for some ideas.See More
Oct 6
Gabriel Nagmay is now a member of University Web Developers
Oct 3
Bill Hartley posted discussions
Oct 2
Geoffrey Campbell is now a member of University Web Developers
Sep 27
Colleen Brennan-Barry posted a discussion

NOW HIRING: Operations Director

Position Title:Operations Director of the Higher Education Web Professionals Association Position Overview:Reporting to the President of the Higher Education Web Professionals Association (www.highedweb.org), the Operations Director is responsible for coordinating the day-to-day operations of the Association and its volunteers. The Operations Director will work with the Board of Directors to facilitate the implementation of a strategic plan, and lay the…See More
Sep 18
Lauren Zakich commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Upcoming webcast: Join Robin Kelly from the University of Texas at Tyler as she shares tips and tricks to improve productivity as a web professional. Register today!"
Sep 11
Eloine Chapman replied to Eloine Chapman's discussion Should we migrate to https?
"Thanks Barb!"
Sep 1
Eloine Chapman replied to Eloine Chapman's discussion Should we migrate to https?
"Thanks Jason!"
Sep 1
Elizabeth Hyde-Copeland is now a member of University Web Developers
Aug 30
Gavin Younger is now a member of University Web Developers
Aug 24
Lauren Zakich commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Our 2018 OmniUpdate User Training Conference will be held in Anaheim on March 25 - 29! Speak at OUTC and you could receive free registration. Submit your proposal today!"
Aug 18
Jason Brady replied to Eloine Chapman's discussion Should we migrate to https?
"We have started the move to make all our sites HTTPS. With our InCommon membership (paid by our State Chancellor's Ofice), we get free certificates, so there is no ongoing costs. In 2014, Google said they give some SEO bumps to HTTPS sites.…"
Aug 18
Profile IconMichael Harvey, Bill Hartley and Jeff Dobbin joined University Web Developers
Aug 18
Barb Iannucci replied to Eloine Chapman's discussion Should we migrate to https?
"Yep, I got the same messages. Some of our sites use SSL and we've been talking about migrating all the rest our sites for a while now. I suspect we will be doing it rather than just talking about it sooner rather than later now. :\"
Aug 18
Eloine Chapman posted a discussion

Should we migrate to https?

I recently got a notice from Google that in October 2017 Chrome V62 with show the warning "NOT SECURE" on all our web pages we have a input field for search. Since on most of our pages there is nothing that would require secure information I've never felt the need for HTTPS. Our class registration pages are secure but not the general information pages. The warning is going to scare people though. Are others upgrading their websites?See More
Aug 17
Colleen Brennan-Barry posted a discussion

HighEdWeb 2017 Early-Bird Pricing available through July 31

It’s the last week get HighEdWeb 2017 early-bird registration pricing! When you register for the Annual Conference by the end of Monday, July 31, you save $100 — and who doesn’t love that?!Register by July 31 to save $100…See More
Jul 25
Lauren Zakich commented on Lynn Zawie's group OmniUpdate
"Upcoming webcast: Join Angela Cavaliere from Montgomery County Community College as she demonstrates how to perform user testing to improve overall web experience. Register today!"
Jul 12
Michael E Matzkin joined Mark Greenfield's group
Thumbnail

WordPress

This group is for all those using WordPress as both a blogging platform and as a CMS
Jul 10
Dan Bashaw commented on Mark Greenfield's group WordPress
"Hi Samuel – WordPress will be a good choice for this kind of project. Can you let us know more about what features you are thinking of adding? It seems to me that a combination of a WordPress site and tightly integrated social media channels…"
Jun 29

UWEBD has been in existence for more than 10 years and is the very best email discussion list on the Internet, in any industry, on any topic

About

© 2017   Created by Mark Greenfield.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service