Share 'Athletics wants their own site. Should I cut them loose?'

I'm in a bit of a conundrum and I'm looking for a little advice... Here's the deal, we redesigned our site roughly a year-and-a-half ago and included athletics on that redesign. The SID at the time was named a stakeholder in the redesign group due to the fact that athletics is one of our top destinations. The SID was fairly uninterested in the whole process and basically checked out. Now they'r…